Why the 5 Stars:
The wool fabric and the mesh lining on this item is outstanding. I mean the best. It was comfortable, seemed like it would breathe well and be warm but not stifling. Gives an active/athletic feel to it. The additional arm and shoulder panels also give a sporty vibe--really cool with the two arm patches, a choice of embroidered or leather.
The asymmetric zipper is cool, but starts to create practical problems if you don't wear it zipped. If worn open it creates an oddly-weighted feel and gap in front. I think the designers realized this, because there is a wide snow panel behind the zipper that attempts to even out the sides a bit. It's a good idea, but because the panel is lighter fabric than the shell there is still an off-weighted feel to it unless it's worn zipped up. Suggestion for A&M: Give it a powder skirt underneath. This would help anchor the jacket weight allow it be worn open without leaning. Better yet, just put the zipper in the middle.
Why I Sent It Back:
For all the athletic appeal of the construction, the fit is not athletic. It's a square, boxy cut. I'm sure it fits others, but it does not fit me. For reference, I got size large. I'm 6'2", 44" chest, 35" waist, 34/35" sleeve for dress shirts. The fit was perfect through the shoulders, a bit wide through the stomach, and a tad short in the arms.
A couple of other suggestions: put powder cuff liners and make adjustable cuffs. I have the '27 downhill parka from A&M and it has…
